Follow Your Nose

I recently dated this boy who seduced me with the way he smelled. In the sense that (Haha! Sense! Get it?) it was only after I got a whiff of him while we stood side by side playing an arcade game that I realized just how badly I wanted to erm...smell him.

Anyway, I'm not dating this boy anymore, and though it ended on good terms it's kind of too awkward to call him up and ask what cologne or soap he uses. (That IS awkward, right? Because I've thought about doing this...but so far I've kept myself in check). But damn I need to replicate that smell!

A friend told me that for a guy in his twenties, it could only be one of three things: Old Spice, something I forgot, or something else I forgot. And I also forgot who told me this...so please speak up if it was you. Yesterday I stopped into Rite Aid to sample their selection of Old Spice. Definitely not it. What do I do next?